Feeling uncoachable? You're not the problem. Here's what $35K of coaching and a shelf of wereshark romance novels taught me about writing your own story.
I learned more about growth and self-sovereignty from weresharks than I did from $35,000 of coaching. Yes, weresharks. As in people who turn into sharks, fall in love, and occasionally avenge their mates. We'll get there.
First, though, this one is for you if you've ever felt uncoachable. Maybe you felt frustrated, or even ashamed, for not following someone else's program. Maybe you watched other women thrive in the same container where you floundered, and wondered why the method working so beautifully for them kept dying in your hands, even when you did exactly what was recommended.
Here's the short version: "uncoachable" is usually a genre mismatch, not a character flaw. The International Coaching Federation counted 122,974 coach practitioners worldwide in its 2025 Global Coaching Study, and every one of them teaches from the story that worked for her. When your story belongs to a different genre, the trouble is the fit, and it was never you.
And no, we're not having the "it's JUST your energy" conversation, because that only hands you a new thing to shame yourself about. Instead of your work ethic or your learning capacity, now you're failing at being high-vibe and grateful 24/7. Energy CAN be part of the equation, but that conversation has been done to DEATH, and this one hasn't.
What Does "Uncoachable" Actually Mean?
"Uncoachable" is a label coaches give clients who don't follow the program as written, and it usually says more about the program than about the client. It tends to arrive with its cousins, "you didn't want it badly enough" and "you're just not committed."
I got an email recently claiming coachability is the BIGGEST difference between successful and unsuccessful people. It went on to shame the supposed know-it-alls who end up broke and struggling. Maybe that marketing attracts someone with a shame kink, but when I see coaches shitting on people for being "uncoachable," that's a big red flag for me.
The research sides with the so-called know-it-alls. Self-determination theory, the motivation framework psychologists Richard Ryan and Edward Deci laid out in American Psychologist in 2000, names autonomy (the felt sense that you are choosing your own actions) as one of three basic psychological needs, alongside competence and relatedness. When those needs get thwarted, motivation and well-being drop.
I don't think anyone is uncoachable. I think people want to write their own story instead of plagiarizing someone else's, word for word and line by line. That level of sovereignty deserves celebration, not derision.
The Coaching Call That Woke My Chaos Dragon
This episode started with a coaching call that left one of my business besties feeling worse than before she dialed in. I'm sharing the general details with her permission.
She wanted to run her business a particular way, which was social-media-free and email-based, with automations that free up her time to actually serve her clients. Her mentor's answer was, basically, that method won't work for you. You're not far enough along. You have to be in people's DMs in the beginning to get your first clients.
She showed up for inspiration, direction, and clarity, and she left with the opposite.
My little Chaos Dragon is my name for the fiercely protective, fire-breathing part of me, and you can meet her properly in the episode about why an untrained Chaos Dragon will eat your husband. She got VERY fired up on my friend's behalf, partly because I'm protective of my friends, and partly because I've sat on that side of the call so many times myself. I think a lot of us have.
Where Did $35.7K of Coaching Go?
I did the math on every coaching container that left me disenchanted, confused, and less connected to myself and my goals, and the total came to about $35,700. There was a time I wouldn't have admitted that number out loud, because spending that much without a clear ROI felt shameful. In some cases, it felt more like a negative ROI.
It turns out it wasn't. Those containers showed me how to lead my own differently, and they gave me the lived experience to say all of this to the women who need to hear it. If you've ever wondered whether flunking every program makes you the problem, I've made the case before that failing every wellness program was actually the right answer.
Two things about that number. It only counts the containers where I learned this specific what-not-to-do lesson. And I'm not throwing shade at any specific coach, because they weren't bad coaches or bad people. Even the container that gave me real energetic shifts, ones I'd pay for again, still ran the same pattern. Write in my genre, not yours.
That same coach also told me to spend hours on social media instead of building my book funnel, which is a sales path where one low-priced book introduces readers to the rest of my work. That funnel is now the engine of a business I actually LOVE, and it's how my work reaches the women who need it.
Why Do Coaches Say "That Won't Work for You"?
When a mentor tells you your approach can't work, what she often means is "I don't know how to write in that genre." Every one of those containers had this in common. They were trying to force me to write a story in a genre I hated.
It happens constantly in the coaching industry, which the ICF's 2025 study sized at $5.34 billion in annual revenue. A coach sees another author and wants her to write the exact story that got the coach her own results, with the same tropes, the same story beats, and the same ending. Your story can't work, apparently, because she doesn't know how to write it.
That's what happened to my friend. She wanted to write in HER genre, and a coach with no experience in that genre told her to switch.
Meanwhile, I guarantee you there is someone out there writing in that genre and thriving. Which brings us to the sharks.
So, About the Weresharks
Shifter romance is full of werewolves, werebears, werelions, and wereleopards, and I wanted to write about weresharks. There are even wererats, plus that one wereswan who exploded into feathers in one of Laurell K. Hamilton's Anita Blake novels that one time.
I didn't think weresharks had been done before, so I checked. And lo and behold, I found Passions of the Wereshark by Jack Madique. The last name is spelled M-A-D-I-Q-U-E, but let's be real, you could pronounce it "Ma Dick," making it Jack Ma Dick. I am fairly certain this was intentional.
Then there's Wereshark Cove by Eden Redd, Caught by the Wereshark by Clara Karll, and Wereshark's Lust by Calyope Adams. Goodreads has a whole list of wereshark books with seven titles on it, and they have ratings and reviews on Amazon too. So it's not done as often as werewolves and weretigers, but it's been done, and people are reading it.
And maybe the thing you want to do actually hasn't been done before. That doesn't mean it won't work. Maybe you just have to be like Jack Madique and go first so others can follow, filthy pen name not necessarily required. A big thank you to Jack for going first so I could go on to write the Pacific Heat shark shifter trilogy.
Is There One Right Diet or Business Model for Everyone?
No single diet or business model is right for everyone, and the diet research is blunt about it. In the DIETFITS trial published in JAMA in 2018, Stanford's Christopher Gardner and his team followed 609 adults for a year on either a healthy low-fat or a healthy low-carb diet. Average weight change was nearly identical between the two, and inside each group results ranged from roughly 30 kilograms lost to 10 gained.
Same manuscript, wildly different readers. That's why the wars between paleo, keto, and vegan never end. People get dogmatic about their way of getting into amazing health because it worked for them and it fit their story.
Business runs the same way. Most people have business models as common as werewolves and vampires, like the social-media-heavy influencer model, or the DM drive-bys with the tracking spreadsheet. Those models work, and the people using them aren't wrong.
But maybe you don't even like paranormal romance, period. Then it's your story, and you can choose another genre entirely. Can you imagine if the only books we had to read were Twilight and J.R. Ward's Black Dagger Brotherhood series? That isn't a dig on either one (you guys KNOW I love my vampire warriors), but we'd get hella bored reading those over and over if they were all we had.
Steal Tropes, Not Manuscripts
The biggest thing weresharks taught me is to steal tropes, not manuscripts. A trope is a recurring story ingredient, like enemies-to-lovers or the chosen one, and a manuscript is somebody's entire finished book. You can borrow the first without photocopying the second.
You don't have to invent from scratch. If you LOVE a slow-burn, best-friends-to-lovers M/M romance, you can write one, and yes, Pacific Heat is a trilogy that ends in exactly that romance after I built it up for two books. But Tyson and Austin are not Blay and Qhuinn from the Black Dagger Brotherhood. They have different backstories and a different plot, and they're a different breed of supernatural being. Those boys provided the inspiration, and I wove it into my own creative work.
(If you've ever wondered why so many women love those stories in the first place, I have a whole episode on how M/M fan fiction builds safety and self-trust.)
The same goes for your business and your body. Certifications that give you new skills to weave into your craft are beautiful. If you love a method someone has for creating content, implement it. And if you've discovered that intermittent fasting or going paleo makes you feel your healthiest and most alive, yes, please keep doing those things.
You Can Skip the Tropes You Hate
You don't have to copy every trope your favourite authors use, either. You'll never see me use the pregnancy trope in a big way. Across my seven novels I can think of one pregnant character, and (spoiler alert) she was Daxton's wereshark mate in the first Pacific Heat book. Shark finners killed her, which gave Daxton his motivation for vengeance. Other authors love a pregnancy storyline, and they should keep writing them.
If your business coach has had great success sending 50 DMs every day and you feel like a sleazeball doing it, that's not your trope.
If your health coach has gotten epic results from cooking every single meal from scratch, but you love leftovers and don't want to bring a hot plate to work and get roasted by your coworkers, don't borrow that one. A side note here: when someone is already overstressed from a big life change and moving through some big emotional stuff, adding from-scratch cooking and a workplace hot plate is probably going to deplete her even more. Ask me how I know.
Does This Mean You Should Never Hire a Coach?
No. Good coaching gives you structure without the dogma. That $35K wasn't every dollar I've invested in coaching. I've spent at least that much, if not more, on incredible programs and mentorships that were deeply instrumental in my growth, and what they had in common was structure that didn't come with "my way, or you're uncommitted."
That's the beautiful thing about stories. They still have structure. There are beginnings, middles, ends, and climaxes. You choose the conflicts and the plot points, you pick a point of view, and there's going to be a theme. Then you let that structure guide the writing.
So my invitation is to stop trying to be more "coachable" (ugh, that word can die in a fire) and start being more intentional about the story you want to write. As we covered in episode 279, where I argued that not all restriction is diet culture, the storyline gets to fit the woman writing it.
And if you're noticing how often you've handed the pen to somebody else, the episode on escaping the validation trap and writing your own ticket pairs well with this one.
Your Embodied Activation: The Trope Audit
A trope audit is a quick inventory of every element in your current approach, sorted by whether you actually want it in your story. You can run one on your business, your health, your fitness, or anywhere that's been feeling flat and stagnant.
List every element of your approach to that area. Every habit, rule, tactic, and "should" goes on the page.
Ask yourself which of these tropes you actually like and want included in your story.
Mark the ones you don't want to keep using.
Add anything you've always wanted to include but haven't tried yet, because this is your chance to experiment.
Keep the list, and change just one or two things to start. You can keep working on your rewrite over time.
If you start this now, you'll already have some powerful revisions done by the time the new year arrives, and you'll walk into it with more momentum and clarity.
FAQs: Feeling Uncoachable
Q: What does it mean to be uncoachable? A: "Uncoachable" is a label for someone who doesn't follow a coach's method as prescribed. In my experience, it usually describes a mismatch between the client's goals and the coach's playbook. Wanting to adapt a method, question it, or build something your coach has never built is authorship, and it doesn't make you difficult.
Q: Is being uncoachable a bad thing? A: Not necessarily. Self-determination theory (Richard Ryan and Edward Deci, 2000) treats autonomy as a basic psychological need, so resisting a plan that overrides your own judgment can be a healthy signal. The useful question is whether you're resisting all structure, or only the structure that doesn't fit your story.
Q: Why isn't my coaching program working for me when it works for everyone else? A: A program can be sound and still be the wrong genre for you. In Stanford's DIETFITS trial (JAMA, 2018), people who followed the same diet for a year ended up everywhere from large losses to gains. Identical instructions produce different results in different lives, and that says nothing about your work ethic.
Q: What are the red flags in a business or health coach? A: The big ones are a coach who meets an unfamiliar strategy with "that won't work" instead of curiosity, a coach who markets by shaming people as uncoachable or uncommitted, and a coach who requires you to copy her model exactly. A good coach offers structure you can adapt and treats you as the author.
Q: Should I stop investing in coaching altogether? A: No. I've spent at least as much on programs that changed my life as on the ones that didn't. I look for structure without dogma, meaning frameworks, skills, and feedback I can weave into my own approach. Steal the tropes you love and leave the manuscript.
You Were Never Uncoachable
This is honestly why I want Food Freedom Fantasy in the hands of so many high-performing women who've struggled in rigid coaching programs. If they're anything like me, maybe they've started to believe they're the problem. That they're uncoachable, and that they're never going to succeed.
But maybe what they're hungry for is authorship, not compliance. Maybe they want to write their own story instead of living inside someone else's.
Food Freedom Fantasy is exactly the thing I said I'd pay for again, which is structure without the dogma. The framework takes on the five most common blocks to consistency and food freedom, and the 15+ ReWrite Rituals are yours to make your own. You can grab the book and all its bonuses for $7.99.
The Pacific Heat series lives at embodiedwritingwarrior.com/books. And yes, all the business and marketing people say one CTA per piece of content, but look at me breaking the genre convention like a defiant little brat in her villain era, as usual. (If you only click one, make it the $7.99 one. The sharks aren't going anywhere.)
You were never uncoachable. You just didn't want to ghostwrite someone else's autobiography. Now you get to go have fun writing your own.